Baseball (est. 2010)
- 2022-24 Matthew Hall - UNC Asheville
- 2022-24 Derek Peterson - Montreat College
- 2023-24 J.T. Carter - Anderson University
- 2022-24 Eli Harpalani - Mount St. Mary's University (Md.)
- 2022-24 Ethan Levy - King University (Tenn.)
- 2022-24 Sam Stowe - Newberry College (S.C.)
- 2022-24 Carson Veasey - Barton College
- 2022-24 Reid Withers - Mars Hill University
- 2023-24 Ethan Young - East Carolina University
- 2023-24 Joseph Webb - Liberty University
- 2023-24 Gavin Sentell - North Carolina A&T
- 2022-24 Connor Bradley - Presbyterian College
- 2022-24 Zac Martin - Campbell University
- 2020-23 Jean Carlos Diaz - Bluefield State
- 2021-23 Trey Larkin - Thomas University (Ga.)
- 2021-23 Jesse Madole - Greensboro College
- 2021-23 Aiden Wilson - St. Andrews University
- 2021-23 Isaiah Martin - St. Andrews University
- 2022-23 Tate Abbott - St. Andrews University
- 2022-23 Ian Anderson - Middle Tennessee State University
- 2022-23 Kobie Cushing - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2022-23 Alex Rodriguez - Carolina University
- 2022-23 Luke Osteen - UNC Chapel Hill
- 2022-23 Trace Baker - UNC Wilmington
- 2021-23 Brent Byler - Bluefield University
- 2021-23 Carlos Reynoso - Emory & University University
- 2021-23 Aiken Minton - Middle Tennessee State University
- 2021-23 Matt Beisecker - Bluefield University
- 2021-23 Sean Seale - Bluefield University
- 2021-23 Jordan Spearman - North Greenville University
- 2020-23 J.D. Lewis - Mars Hill University
- 2020-23 Jack Stevens - Tennessee Wesleyan
- 2020-23 Elec Yount - Mars Hill University
- 2021-22 Bailey McGinnis - Western Carolina University
- 2021-22 Justin Porus - North Carolina A&T
-
2021-22 Juan Moreno - Cumberland University
-
2021-22 Troy Shepherd - Georgia Southwestern State University
- 2021-22 Graham Dalton - University of Charleston (West VA)
- 2021-22 Dawrin Ruiz - Mississippi College
- 2021-22 Bryson Hammer - Dallas Baptist University
-
2020-22 Andrew Dye - Limestone University
-
2020-22 Jordan Davis - Georgia Gwinnett College
-
2020-22 Lane Rhodes - Wingate University
-
2020-22 Sam Walker - Bluefield State
-
2020-22 Chance Daquila - Campbell University
-
2020-22 Walker Case - UNC Pembroke
-
2020-22 Masashi Takegama - Texas A&M Texarkana
-
2020-22 Trey Lambert - UNC Greensboro
-
2020-22 Jonah Milchuck - Georgia Sotuhern University
-
2021-22 Cole Cunningham - Emory & Henry College
-
2020-22 Jackie Jimenez - Tabor College
-
2020-22 Noah Carter - Elon University
- 2019-22 Zack Summerville - Francis Marion University
- 2019-22 Jose Vargas - Grambling University
- 2018-21 Brett Eurey - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2020-21 James Goodwin - Georgia Southwestern University
- 2020-21 Brett Banks - UNC Wilmington
- 2020-21 Cooper Sain - North Greenville University
- 2019-21 Chandler Blackwelder - North Greenville University
- 2019-21 Mason Herbert - Young Harris College
- 2019-21 Kye Andress - Anderson University
- 2019-21 James Hinson - Western Carolina University
- 2019-21 Derrius York - Bethume Cookman University
- 2019-21 Will Samuelson - Tusculum University
- 2019-21 Jordan Montgomery - Southern Wesleyan
- 2019-21 Colt Byars - North Greenville University
- 2019-21 Javier Martinez - Grambling State University
- 2019-21 Ian Asken - East Tennessee State University
- 2018-21 Malik Stephens - Bethume Cookman University
- 2018-21 Jackson Brown - Lenoir Rhyne University
- 2019-20 Connor Patterson - Young Harris
- 2019-20 Jacob Marcos - Gardner-Webb University
- 2018-20 Noah Eaker - Coastal Carolina University
- 2018-20 Ryan Healy - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2018-20 David Kennedy - Limestone College
- 2018-20 Austin Blevins - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2018-20 Mac Beam - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2018-20 Andrew Patrick - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2018-20 Storm Mace - Radford University
- 2018-20 Blake Dockery - UNC Charlotte
- 2017-20 Grant Tilley - North Carolia A&T
- 2017-19 Rod Muñoz - Thomas University
- 2017-19 Chris Banks - UNC Asheville
- 2017-19 Greg Collins - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2017-19 Willie Gordon - Presbyterian College
- 2017-19 R.J. Conner - Queens University
- 2017-19 Tyler Campbell - UVA-Wise
- 2017-19 Nic Messina - North Greenville University
- 2018-19 Myles White - North Carolina A&T
- 2017-19 Garrison Burress - UNC Charlotte
- 2017-19 Timothy Davila - North Carolina A&T
- 2017-19 Charles Covington - UNC Charlotte
- 2018-19 Trae Starnes - UNC Charlotte
- 2019 Trent Jones - Towson University
- 2019 Logan Bender - North Carolina State University
- 2017-18 Kyran Russ - Erskine College
- 2017-18 Will Angel - Erskine Colllege
- 2017-18 Madisyn Bolin - Queens College
- 2016-18 Thomas Walden - Limestone College
- 2016-18 Connor Hewell - Belmont Abbey College
- 2016-18 Graham Mitchell - Presbyterian College
- 2016-18 Jimmy Marcelli - Presbyterian College
- 2016-18 Daniel Brinegar - UNC Greensboro
- 2016-18 Hunter Isaacs - Erskine College
- 2016-18 Harry Hatcher - Erskine College
- 2016-18 David Graves - Lipscomb University
- 2016-18 Matthew Dailey - North Greenville University
- 2016-18 Julian Smith - North Carolina State University
- 2017 Daiquon Davenport - Erskine College
- 2016-17 Austin Adams - Belmont-Abbey College
- 2015-17 Bradley Dskewicz - Mars Hill University
- 2015-17 Bailey Garfield - Guilford College
- 2015-17 T.J. Goco - Winston-Salem State University
- 2016-17 Charles Hall - Tusculum College
- 2015-17 Chandler Jenkins - East Carolina University
- 2015-17 Channing Painton - Limestone
- 2015-17 Andrew Tilghman - UNC-Wilmington
- 2016-17 Riley Smith - Appalachian State University
- 2016-17 Walker Smith - Emmanuel College
- 2017 Cole Whitney - Georgia Southen University
- 2016-17 Chris Wright - North Carolina Central University
- 2015-16 Ty Andrus - Wingate University
- 2015 Mason Biddix - Montreat College
- 2015-16 Aaron Biggerstaff - UNC Pembroke
- 2015-16 Jacob Breakfield - Western Carolina University
- 2015-16 Brandon Ford - Winston-Salem State University
- 2015-16 Seth Hubbard - Mars Hill University
- 2016 Grayson McCurry - Mars Hill University
- 2015-16 Randal Ortiz - Winston-Salem State University
- 2015-16 Taylor Purus - Western Carolina University
- 2015-16 Craig Zalewa - Presbyterian College
- 2014-15 Clay Hodges - Western Carolina University
- 2013-15 Andrew Meadows - North Greenville University
- 2014-15 Brandyn Norton - Wingate University
- 2014-15 Trever Lee - Carson-Newman University
- 2014-15 Lou Matarazzo - Iona College
- 2014-15 Landon Fraley - North Carolina Central University
- 2014-15 Danny Sullivan - Gardner Webb University
- 2014-15 Chase Poplin - Mount Olive University
- 2014-15 Will Greene - North Carolina A&T University
- 2014-15 Josh Bottenfield - North Carolina A&T University
- 2014-15 Gavin Huffman - North Carolina A&T University
- 2014-15 Kyle Ramsey - UNC Pembroke
- 2014-15 Alex Minton - UNC Pembroke
- 2014-15 Ivan Acuna - Winston-Salem State University
- 2014-15 Phillip Black - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2014-15 Jake Helms - Winston-Salem State University
- 2015 Bryce Hensley - UNC Greensboro
- 2015 Carson Bryant - Emory and Henry University
- 2014-15 Justin Norton - Winston-Salem State University
- 2013-14 Dustin Batson - Carson Newman
- 2013-14 Bryson Bowman - Western Carolina University
- 2014 Lucas Cash - UNC Asheville
- 2014 Colby Dishmond - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2013-14 Trip Dunn - Mount Olive University
- 2014 Patrick Laganke - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2014 Sam Major - University of Massachusetts
- 2013-14 Ryan Smith - Brevard College
- 2013-14 Avery Sneed - Anderson University
- 2013-14 Stefan Susi - Brevard College
- 2012-13 Colton Allison - Mars Hill College
- 2012-13 Pedro Benavides - Montreat College
- 2012-13 Ryan Karl - Cornell University
- 2012-13 Bill Little - Erskine College
- 2012-13 Aaron Sparks - Emory & Henry University
- 2012-13 Kevin Weissheier - Hofstra University
- 2012-13 Robert Whaley - Appalachian State University
- 2011-2 Rob Cafiero - Hofstra University
- 2011-12 Danny Fraga - UNC Pembroke
- 2011-12 Chris Harkey - Hofstra University
- 2011-12 Brett Huffman - UNC Pembroke
- 2011-12 Jon Millsaps - UNC Pembroke
- 2011-12 Ryan Swartz - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2010-11 Bradley Carpenter - Montreat College
- 2010-11 Tripper Crisson - Tusculum University
- 2010-11 Ethan Johnson - Virginia Intermont University
- 2010-11 Brett Mabry - East Carolina University
- 2009-10 Marshall McDonald - Montreat College
- 2009-10 Corey Warner - Toccoa Falls College
- 2009-10 Aubrey Meadows - UNC Pembroke
- 2009-10 Zack Merriken - Brevard College
Bass Fishing (est. 2019)
- 2019-21 Lane Bailey - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2019-21 Caleb Lonca - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2019-21 Adam Seagle - Erskine College
- 2019-21 Jeremy Dellinger - Erskine College
Esports (est. 2019)
- 2021-23 Hector Santamaria - Newberry College
- 2021-23 Cristian Baquiax - Converse University
- 2021-23 Sky Lee - University of North Carolina at Greensboro
- 2021-23 Bailey Patterson - Cumberland University
- 2021-22 Jesus Andrade-Chavez - Converse University
Men’s Basketball (est. 2004-05)
- 2021-23 Shad Thomas - Catawba College
- 2020-22 Quincy Martin - Newberry College
- 2020-21 Derrick Molden - Mars Hill University
- 2019-21 Tony Hauser - Saint Augustine's University
- 2019-21 Jaylen Prioleau - Erskine College
- 2020-21 E.J. Thomas - Pfeiffer University
- 2018-20 Jahleer Black - Bluefield College
- 2018-20 Byron Sanders - North Carolina Central University
- 2018-20 Jonathan McFall - Chowan University
- 2018-20 Sal-Bey Young - North Carolina Wesleyan College
- 2018-19 Cole Johnson - University of Mount Olive
- 2018-19 Jordan Powell - University of Saint Joseph (Connecticut)
- 2018-19 Brandon Reeves - Ferrum College
- 2017-19 Everett Palmer - Ferrum College
- 2017-19 Victor Tshiona - Montreat College
- 2017-19 Isayah Johnson - Mars Hill University
- 2016-18 Steve Ruszala - Guilford College
- 2016-17 Derick Brewer - Winston Salem State University
- 2015-17 Ty Ireland - Fayetteville State University
- 2015-17 Matthew Powell - Mars Hill University
- 2015-17 Emmanuel Wembi - Lenoir-Rhyne Univeristy
- 2015-17 Nolan Whitener - Pfeiffer University
- 2014-16 Anthony Atkins - Pfeiffer University
- 2014-16 Mon'Darius Black - Dalton State
- 2013-16 Daron Gipson - Greensboro College
- 2014-16 Cornelius Johnson - Greensboro College
- 2014-16 Kenny Lemon - University Northwestern Ohio
- 2013-15 Trevin Miller – Greensboro College
- 2013-14 Darrion Evans – Lenoir Rhyne University
- 2012-14 Brandon McCarter – Mars Hill College
- 2012-14 Cameron Redd – Lees-McCrae College
- 2011-13 Jalen Cannady – North Carolina Wesleyan College
- 2011-13 Isaiah Cuthbertson – Mars Hill College
- 2011-13 Preston Earle – Dalton State College
- 2011-13 Anthony Hilliard – Dalton State College
- 2011-13 Terrance Polk – Emmanuel College
- 2010-12 Zach Hayes - Gardner-Webb University
- 2010-12 Justin Lail - Bluefield College
- 2010-12 Will White – Mars Hills College
- 2006-07 Octreyvius Roebuck - Southern Wesleyan University
- 2006-07 Jeremy Yancey - Ferrum College
Softball (est. 2019)
- 2021-23 Jillian Jones - UVA-Wise
- 2023-25 Kameron Bolick - Erskine College
Women’s Basketball (est. 2009-10)
- 2022-24 Alexia Cunningham - Clinton College
- 2022-24 Rylie Hogg - Carolina University
- 2023-24 Sabrina Lewis - Johnson C. Smith University
- 2022-23 Nijah Cunningham - North Carolina Central University
- 2021-23 Keziah Soogrim - Saint Augustine's University
- 2021-22 Beyonce Jones - Erskine College
- 2021-22 Essence Sumner - Lees-McRae College
- 2021-22 Tre'zha Muhammad - Shaw University
- 2021-22 Azuria Barrino - Greensboro College
- 2021-22 Kelis Carmon - Johnson C. Smihth University
- 2021-22 Alexandria Barrino - Saint Andrew University
- 2020-21 A.J. Davis - Wingate University
- 2019-20 Alliyah Chaplin - Saint Augustine's University/Shaw University
- 2018-20 Tazah Hardin - Carolina University
- 2018-19 Zharia Brown - Montreat College
- 2018-19 Milequa Eason - Saint Augustine's University
- 2018-19 Sherry Johnson - University of Mount Olive
- 2018-19 Danielle Rainey - University of Mount Olive/Saint Augustine's University
- 2016-18 Nikkyana McCaskill - Fayetteville State University
- 2016-18 Joyous Wilson - Mars Hill University
- 2016-18 Tanisha Wall - Saint Augustine's University
- 2016-18 Shaniya Lester - UNC Pembroke
- 2016-17 Ieshia Love - UNC Pembroke
- 2015-17 Aliyah Woods - Greensboro College
- 2015-17 Jala Daniels - Montreat College
- 2015-16 Keyona Hicks - Greensboro College
- 2014-16 Monifa Angle - Piedmont International University
- 2014-16 Ty'Ais Cooper - Elizabeth City State University
- 2014-16 TaKeyra Thomas - Elizabeth City State University
- 2014-15 Shakira Allen - Mars Hill University
- 2014-15 Allison Church - Warren Wilson College
- 2012-14 Kadesha Gibbs – Georgia College and State University
- 2013-14 T’Shea Glenn – Warren Wilson College
- 2012-14 Anika Jones – Johnson C. Smith University
- 2013-14 Maggie Stewart - Queens University
- 2011-13 Matrice Sweezy – Virginia University of Lynchburg
- 2009-11 Kristin Maney – Montreat College
- 2009-10 Gentry Manley – UNC Asheville
- 2009-10 Micheala Watkins – Brevard College
Volleyball (est. 2004)
- 2020-22 Grace Nelson - Emory & Henry
- 2019-21 Aasia McNeill - Elizabeth City State
- 2018-20 Rachel Delcamp - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2018-20 Emma Clark - Georgia State University
- 2018-20 Bre Myers - Mars Hill University
- 2017-18 Sophie Brennan - Winston-Salem State University
- 2017-18 Emilee Webber - Belmont Abbey College
- 2016-17 Adair Melton - Meredith College
- 2017-18 Kara Williams - Montreat College
- 2016-18 Sabrina Pinard - UNC Asheville
- 2016-18 Hailey Tatu - Greensboro College
- 2015-17 McKala Bozman - University of Tennessee at Martin
- 2015-17 Victoria Carter - Montreat College
- 2015-17 Savannah Dishman - Point Park University
- 2015-17 Megan Fair - University of Tennessee at Martin
- 2015-17 Ada Thompson - Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2015-17 Mariah Wallace - Lander University
- 2014-16 Hannah Griffin - Milligan College
- 2014-16 Emily Horn - Greensboro College
- 2014-16 Madison Steed - Johnson & Wales University
- 2013-15 Aimee Cloninger – Belmont Abbey College
- 2013-15 Tiffany Brooks – Lenoir-Rhyne University
- 2013-15 Katie Ruff – Brevard College
- 2013-15 Anna Henderson – UNC Charlotte
- 2013-15 Madison Pogue – North Greenville University
- 2012-14 Leah Wells - UNC Greensboro
- 2012-14 Hannah Lewis - North Greenville University
- 2012-14 Megan Gouge - North Greenville University
- 2012-13 Jennifer Beatty – Embry Riddle Aeronautical University, Florida
- 2012-13 Cecilia Brandon – UNC Pembroke
- 2011-13 Kailey Russell – UNC Pembroke
- 2010-12 Megan Clark – Brevard College
- 2009-11 Francesca Edgerton – Winston-Salem State University